Desk display wins: Monkey Bomb holder or Assassin’s Creed Shadows?
These two products solve very different problems, so the right choice depends on whether you want a gaming accessory or an actual game. Product A is a themed controller and phone stand for your setup, while Product B is a limited edition PS5 game for players who want something to play. If you are comparing them on value, usefulness, and immediate impact on your gaming space, the differences are stark. This head-to-head breaks down which one is the smarter buy for most people.
Cableguys Call of Duty Monkey Bomb Controller Holder & Phone Stand - Gaming Accessories for Room and Desk Setup, Holder Compatible with Xbox, PlayStation & Most Standard Game Controllers
Assassin's Creed Shadows Limited Edition (Exclusive to Amazon.uk) (PS5)
Our Recommendation
Product A is the better buy for most people because it costs half as much, has a stronger 4.8/5 rating from 3,599 reviews, and delivers everyday utility as both a controller holder and phone stand. It also improves your desk or room setup immediately, while Product B only has value if you specifically want to play the game. Unless you are shopping for Assassin’s Creed Shadows itself, the Cableguys Monkey Bomb offers the better mix of price, satisfaction, and usefulness.
Detailed Comparison
Display
Product A wins by default in this category because it is a physical display piece for your desk or room setup. The Cableguys Monkey Bomb is designed to hold an Xbox, PlayStation, or most standard controllers, and it also doubles as a phone stand, so it has an obvious visual and functional presence. Product B is a game disc/edition, so it does not contribute to your room display in the same way. If your priority is making your gaming area look better and keeping gear organized, Product A is the clear winner.
Performance
Product B wins here because it is the only item that actually delivers gameplay performance. Assassin’s Creed Shadows Limited Edition is a PS5 game, so its value comes from the software experience, not from being a physical accessory. Product A performs a utility role well, but it does not improve frame rate, responsiveness, or gameplay quality. If you want something that affects what you play, Product B is the only real choice.
Build quality and design
Product A wins on design and likely on durability as a desk object. Cableguys has a strong reputation for sculpted, character-based holder designs, and the Monkey Bomb theme from Call of Duty is instantly recognizable to fans. With 4.8/5 from 3,599 reviews, it has a stronger approval signal than Product B’s 4.6/5 from 1,434 reviews, suggesting buyers are especially happy with its build and presentation. Product B’s limited edition packaging may be attractive to collectors, but the product itself is still primarily a game purchase rather than a premium physical accessory.
Battery life
Neither product has battery life in the usual sense, so this category is not directly applicable. Product A can help reduce clutter by giving your controller and phone a fixed resting place, which may indirectly support better day-to-day convenience, but it does not charge devices. Product B is a game and has no battery-related function at all. This is effectively a tie, but it does not change the buying decision.
Price and value for money
Product A wins decisively on value. At £14.99, it is £14.99 cheaper than Product B, which costs £29.98, meaning you pay about half as much for a highly rated, practical accessory. With 3,599 reviews and a 4.8/5 rating, Product A looks like a low-risk purchase that delivers immediate utility. Product B may justify its higher price if you specifically want the game and its limited edition status, but purely on cost-per-benefit, the controller holder offers more visible everyday value for less money.
Game library/features
Product B wins this category because it is an actual game with content, gameplay, and replay value. Assassin’s Creed Shadows Limited Edition for PS5 gives you access to Ubisoft’s open-world action experience, while the limited edition label suggests some extra collector appeal or bonus packaging beyond the base game. Product A has no game library at all; its only features are controller storage and phone holding. If you are looking for entertainment content rather than furniture-like utility, Product B is the only product that fits.
Overall user experience
Product A is the better overall experience for most buyers because it solves a daily problem: where to put your controller and phone while also improving the look of your setup. Its very strong review count and top-tier rating point to broad satisfaction, and the lower £14.99 price makes it an easy add-on purchase. Product B offers a much larger entertainment payoff if you want a new PS5 title, but that value depends entirely on whether you actually want to play Assassin’s Creed Shadows. For a general buyer comparing these two listings head-to-head, Product A is the more universally useful and lower-risk buy.
Overall summary: Product A wins the comparison on price, ratings, practicality, and setup value. Product B only wins if your main goal is buying a PS5 game to play right now. If you want the smarter all-around purchase, choose Product A; if you want entertainment content and specifically want Assassin’s Creed Shadows, choose Product B.
Buy the Cableguys Call of if...
Buy Product A if you want a practical gaming accessory that keeps your controller and phone organized while adding character to your setup. It is especially smart if you already own plenty of games and want something useful for your desk at a low £14.99 price. It is also the safer choice if you care about strong buyer satisfaction and broad controller compatibility.
Buy the Assassin's Creed Shadows if...
Buy Product B if your real goal is to play Assassin’s Creed Shadows on PS5 and you want the limited edition version from Amazon UK. It makes sense if you value game content over accessories and are happy paying £29.98 for a new release or collector-oriented edition. Choose this only if you specifically want the software experience, not desk organization.
Curated by Light Gun Gamer on All The Top Picks
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.