Which Brother sewing machine gives you more for your money?
If you’re choosing between these two Brother machines, you’re really deciding between a slightly pricier model with fewer reviews and a lower-cost option with a huge user base. Both have an excellent 4.7/5 rating, so this is less about quality gaps and more about which machine suits your sewing habits, budget, and confidence level. For UK buyers, the difference of £16 may feel small, but it can still matter when you’re balancing accessories, thread, and fabric costs. Here’s the practical verdict on which one to buy.
Brother LS14S Metal Chassis Sewing Machine, 43.9 x 18.9 x 36 cm White
Our Recommendation
The Brother LS14S Metal Chassis Sewing Machine is the better overall buy because it costs £16 less, has the same excellent 4.7/5 rating as the AE1700, and has far more reviews behind it. Its metal chassis also suggests a sturdier, more stable sewing experience, which is especially reassuring for beginners and everyday home sewing. Unless you specifically want the AE1700’s 17-stitch flexibility, the LS14S gives you the better mix of value and confidence.
Detailed Comparison
Display
Neither machine is defined by a display in the way an electronic model would be, so this category is mostly about usability and how clearly the machine communicates settings. Based on the product names and positioning, both are straightforward mechanical Brother machines rather than screen-led models. That means there’s no meaningful display advantage for either one. Winner: tie.
Performance
Product A, the Brother AE1700 17-Stitch Sewing Machine, offers 17 stitches, which gives you a bit more flexibility for everyday sewing, repairs, and decorative finishing. Product B, the Brother LS14S Metal Chassis Sewing Machine, is presented more as a sturdy, no-fuss workhorse, but the listing here doesn’t highlight a stitch count as clearly as Product A. If you want a little more stitch variety for hems, seams, and occasional creative work, Product A has the edge on paper. However, both share the same 4.7/5 rating, and Product B has far more reviews at 7,107 versus 1,947, which suggests very consistent real-world performance across a larger user base. Winner: Product A for stitch versatility, but only narrowly.
Build quality and design
This is where Product B pulls ahead. The Brother LS14S is specifically described as a Metal Chassis Sewing Machine, which is a strong clue that it should feel more rigid and stable during sewing, especially on thicker fabrics or at higher speeds. Product A’s title does not emphasise a metal chassis, so it is less obviously built for that level of solidity. In practical sewing terms, a metal chassis usually means less vibration, a steadier stitch, and a machine that feels more confidence-inspiring over time. The LS14S also has a compact footprint listed at 43.9 x 18.9 x 36 cm, which is helpful for small sewing corners. Winner: Product B.
Battery life
Neither of these is a battery-powered machine, so battery life is not a relevant differentiator. In a real sewing-room sense, both are mains-powered machines intended for home use. There is no advantage to either product here. Winner: tie.
Price and value for money
Product B is the clear value winner on price: £99.00 compared with Product A at £115.00, a saving of £16.00. That matters because both machines share the same excellent 4.7/5 rating, so you are not paying extra for a noticeably better reputation. In fact, Product B has the stronger review volume, with 7,107 reviews versus 1,947 for Product A, which gives the cheaper machine a very persuasive value story. Unless you specifically want the extra stitch count of Product A, Product B is the smarter buy for most people. Winner: Product B.
Game library/features
For sewing machines, this is best understood as stitch options and practical features rather than a game library. Product A’s 17 stitches are its clearest feature advantage, giving you more choice for utility stitches and decorative touches. Product B’s strength lies less in variety and more in dependable, proven ownership: the metal chassis design, the lower price, and the huge review count all point to a machine people trust for everyday use. If you’re a beginner or someone who mainly wants a reliable machine for alterations, mending, and simple projects, Product B offers the better feature-to-price balance. If you know you’ll use the extra stitch options, Product A is the more feature-rich choice. Winner: Product A for features, Product B for practical value.
Overall user experience
This is the closest category, because both machines are highly rated and both come from Brother, a brand with a strong reputation for approachable home sewing. Product A feels like the slightly more capable option on paper, thanks to its 17-stitch specification. Product B feels like the more sensible everyday machine: cheaper, backed by many more reviews, and explicitly built on a metal chassis for stability. For most UK buyers, that combination makes the LS14S easier to recommend because it hits the sweet spot of price, confidence, and durability. Winner: Product B.
Overall summary: The Brother AE1700 is the better choice if you want a little more stitch variety and don’t mind paying £16 extra. But the Brother LS14S Metal Chassis Sewing Machine is the better all-round buy for most people because it is cheaper, has a metal chassis for sturdier sewing, and is supported by a much larger pool of positive reviews. Both are excellent at 4.7/5, but Product B delivers the stronger value and the safer recommendation.
Buy the Brother AE1700 17-Stitch if...
Buy Product A if you know you will use the extra stitch options and want a slightly more versatile machine for decorative finishing or varied household sewing. It also makes sense if you prefer choosing the model with the explicit 17-stitch feature set, even at a small premium.
Buy the Brother LS14S Metal if...
Buy Product B if you want the best value, a more stable-feeling machine, and the reassurance of a much larger review base. It is the better choice for beginners, practical mending, and everyday sewing where reliability matters more than extra stitch variety.
Curated by Stitch & Create on All The Top Picks
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.